Old World Pizza

Guestbook

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

166 Comments

Reply Myrna
9:56 AM on August 19, 2014 

Pizza ordered off the menu is the best.

Reply Not An Idiot
4:32 PM on July 14, 2014 

If you are eating Old World pizza for the buffet you're doing it wrong.

This is the best pizza in Minnesota, if not in the Midwest.  I've been eating it for decades.  Ask my doctor, he reminds me of it yearly.

I won't eat the buffet for all of the reasons listed below.  The buffet still good pizza, however the presentation and temperature are usually below the extremely high standards I have for Old World.  A freshly made to order pie either in the restaraunt or delivered is simply the only way to go.  Honestly I hate the fact that they do the buffet on Monday and Tuesday nights because it is too much of a zoo in there with all of the yoga pants wearing hogs in there with their five kids and full-mullet muscle shirt (ironically not a lot of muscle there) wearing husbands pushing their way through the line.  It is a sad pile of humanity nervously trying to make sure no one else eats THEIR pizza by taking nine slices at a time.  That's the world we live in now!

I love the wait staff, new location and will continue to heavily patronize Old World Pizza.  It is my favorite place to eat.  I do not understand why people go so wild about the buffet though.  Eat the real deal and enjoy pizza the way it was meant to be made and served.

Reply Buck Snifler
7:50 PM on July 8, 2014 

Best Pizza in Minnesota

Reply Kari
3:00 PM on June 17, 2014 

You have the BEST pizza anywhere - the new location is beautiful - however I think you have too much restaurant and not enough pizza on the buffet line - there is definately something wrong with how it works now in the new location vs. how it worked at the old location. It is frustrating - there are too many people in line and when you do get to the pizza some of it is simply not that appealing. You would think that with as many people as there are it would turn over really quick and always be fresh and new. I love the idea other customers have posted on here to open up the back and have that second buffet line. You are going to have to do something. We are weekly customers, plan to be there tonight. But wondering how it will be. We won't be back if it continues to have the lag and line that it currently does. Brian - you have become so successful - I know you will figure it out and that it will improve. There are growing pains with a new location layout. But don't let the growing pains ruin your reputation. Let's make an improvement quick! EVERYONE LOVES YOUR PIZZA - EVERYONE HATES LONG LINES.... GOOD LUCK

 

Reply ALI
1:38 PM on June 4, 2014 

Best personal Pizza in town, thank you

Reply Nicole
8:43 PM on June 2, 2014 

Old World has been our favorite pizza place for the past 10 years.  Between delivery and the buffet, we probably eat Old Work 5 times a month.  However, our experience at the buffet since the move has been terrible. We gave it a couple of tries, but  I don't think we will be back :(  Waiting in line for 10 minutes only to find there is no pizza left is very disappointing.  At the old location, there was rarely a line and always a fantastic selection! I'm not sure why it has changed.  I overheard the couple next to us tonight say that they woundn't come back anymore because it's not worth the hassle.  We may still order delivery, but the buffet is no longer worth the cost. 

Reply Stephen tuccitto
7:14 PM on June 2, 2014 
So I am guessing when I have take out, And one of my pizzas is cut into skinny wedges, This pizza was meant for your buffet. This is twice this has happened. My meatless marvel is hot and cut square, and the pepperoni is cold And cut into skimpy wedges. BOGUS very disappointed . I have a general Idea what your food cost is on these pizzas. Therefore , my pizzas should ALWAYS BE FRESH!!!! Thanks for your time.
Reply Steve
3:35 PM on May 31, 2014 

I was just eating lunch here the other day and I also became very frustrated with the lack of pizza selections and the long long lines forming from both ends of the buffet line. People were glaring at each other and it was very comedic. I was told you moved to this location so there would be less waiting and that you outgrew the old location. The irony is that now there are more lines, less pizza, and less customers coming because of this situation.

 

Everybody I talk to agrees that you have great pizzas but stop being so stupid and not listen to your employees and customers! Open up the back room for a second buffet line and your avid followers (like my friends and I) will come back more often. That seems to be a Win-Win for everybody.

 

I also believe you have a good and friendly wait staff always very attentive to clearing empty plates and refilling our drinks. I was told by one of them that you finally tried putting pizzas on the back buffet and the whole restaurant started clapping! Why stop? Charge more money for the buffet if it is an expense issue and myself and others will gladly pay more for the buffet and for the convenience of not having to wait in line at only one station.

 

Wishing you guys the best and please make a change.

 

Reply Pizza Lover
8:28 AM on May 30, 2014 

You Guys are "missing the boat and your customers are falling off the sinking ship!"

I have been enjoying your great pizza and your even greater wait staff for several years. I have brought several groups and friends with me from all over the Twin Cities during that time. All of us have complained about the TERRIBLE SET UP with only one line and it has gotten us nowhere. PLEASE STOP BEING STUBBORN AND TAKE PRESSURE OFF YOUR STAFF BY OPENING THE BACK AREA FOR A SECOND BUFFET LINE.

I am well aware of ALL the complaints you receive about this on a daily basis. Just ask any customer that is there if they have been to your old place and ask them what they think about your new location. The answers will be very similar....same great pizza, same great wait staff, very nice new location but...........waiting in line in a confined corridor and less pizza choices (due to only one buffet line) is AWFUL!

The old place worked so well that my friends and I knew we had to get there before 11:45 (because all of the tables would be filled up) and there would be a line out the door. The difference is people were willing to wait to be seated, but once seated, would enjoy the selection and availability of 2 buffet lines. NOW there is never a line for seating (due to people not coming as often). The only line now is the wait for pizza to arrive or just too many people at the single buffet line. I have even seen a huge line form from both ends on several occasions (very, very frustrating)??

Please take care of this problem or continue to go down with your "titanic" believing that your ship is also invincible and will never sink.....good pizza will only keep people coming back for so long....one terrible dining experience will lose customers for life!

Reply Carol Tegantvoort
12:39 PM on May 14, 2014 

My Family...all 25 of us...would like to thank you for  a wonderful experience at your restaurant this past Sunday...Mothers Day. Your pizza is definitely the best ever. The dessert oreo pizza made a big hit with my grandkids, I loved the salad Bar and my adult kids found your pasta choices to be very good! So as you can see we were all very pleased. To top this all off Brian and our sweet well organized waitress went far and above the call of duty to make this a wonderful day for all of us Mothers and my family. We wanted to take the time to say a huge "Thank You" and to let you know we definitely would recommend your Old Word Pizza there in IGH to everyone! Again THANK YOU Brian and special thank you to our wonderful waitress! (i wish i remembered her name)

Reply Rory
7:36 PM on April 23, 2014 

Myself and a group of coworkers have been enjoying your lunch buffet for years. The food, service and atmosphere have always been top notch! We are always greeted warmly, and requests for a specific pizza are quickly obliged.

The restaurant size and seating at you new location is great. However, both times we’ve been there this April, the buffet line and selection have been frustrating. The selection of pizza is far less than the old location (that had two separate buffet lines). There were several times today when there were only a couple of pizza selections available. Additionally, the setup of the buffet doesn’t appear to be working as you intended it to. The multiple “stations” idea hasn’t caught on, and it takes much more time to navigate. Since we have limited time to eat our lunch and get back to work, this has become a problem for us that never existed at the old location. I’m sure you are going through a lot of growing pains with the move, and sincerely hope that you are able to work through them quickly.

Reply Jack Frost
12:54 AM on April 18, 2014 

So much space for me to sprawl out and swim in your awesome pizza now! I totally disagree with "Worst service ever..." comment, though.  Other than not having the red carpet rolled out for me and a BBQ chicken pizza waiting for me at table #71 on Grand Opening Friday, I'd say the staff here is second to squat. I sincerely wish your business the greatest continued success- you have a customer for life!

Reply Robyn
3:15 PM on March 5, 2014 

Love your Pizza!!

Buffet is an awesome way to have lunch!

Reply mark evangelist
9:31 AM on March 5, 2014 

I would like to buy some of your italian sausage. It is the best I have ever tasted. Where do you purchase it from?

Reply Julie
1:34 PM on February 20, 2014 

I work in the customer service field and feel like when you're doing a GREAT JOB and have a GREAT PRODUCT no one comments.  It's only when someone is unhappy that they write reviews.  So I am writting so today to say "thumbs up"  Not only do you provide wonderful customer service, but you have the BEST pizza around!

Reply Pattie
9:44 AM on February 14, 2014 

I want to thank you for one of the best pizza ever.  I have enjoyed your pizza since I was a little girl and hope that It will be there for the rest of my life.. I remember the old place with the pac man game and the juke box but the new place is awesome.  congrads and thanks again for a great product.  Pattie

 

Reply Gretchen
12:34 PM on January 23, 2014 

My husband and I love your pizzas!! We use to live in West Saint Paul and we would go to the buffet on a Monday or Tuesday. We moved to Forest Lake almost 4 years ago and we still try to get over there to get your yummy pizza. Thanks for the great pizza!

Reply Linda
1:25 PM on January 17, 2014 

My husband and I visited Old World Pizza every week for our "pizza night" date......until I found out I had a gluten allergy.  Please offer a gluten free crust option.  We miss our visits to our favorite neighborhood pizza place.

The French Meadow Bakery in Minneapolis offers wonderful gluten-free crusts.  They come in their own aluminum pan so they're easy to bake.

The Bittersweet bakery in Eagan also offers gluten free pizza crust.  The Tavern in Woodbury uses this crust for their gluten free pizza.

I hope to see gluten free pizza offerings soon!  I do appreciate your salad bar and we did stop in once for a salad dinner, but the smell of pizza is so wonderful......I really felt like I was missing something when pizza was not a choice on my plate.

Reply Paul Hurley
2:46 PM on November 27, 2013 

Two co-workers went to lunch there today and I asked them to bring me a Pizza for me to bring home for my boys. I tried a piece, it is very good, glad I had them bring me one!

Reply Eddy Parke
12:38 PM on November 23, 2013 
One the best. From crust, sauce, and toppings. Just excellent.
Reply Bruce
9:40 PM on October 28, 2013 

Simply the one of the best 

Reply Worst service ever...
11:02 PM on October 19, 2013 

I really wish I would of got the name of the rude waitress that we had this last Friday. I'm not the kind of person to complain about these kind of things but she was so awful that something needs to be said. The things that she said to us was so rude and uncalled for that as long as she works there we will never return. What a horrid young lady who clearly doesn't know what customer service is. The other employees were nice and the food was good but having somone working there that is so rude and disrespectful makes this place the kind of one that isn't worth the headache to return to. 

Reply Barb
10:35 PM on October 10, 2013 

Got the BLT pizza tonight.   Consistency would be good. Not one of the best ones I've had. does anyone at the place ever read these or care what the customers have to say? 

Reply Geri Robinette
3:02 PM on October 7, 2013 

We love eating at Old World, but I want to especially say thank you for the great pizza party party last Saturday night. It was affordable and the service was great. Thanks on behalf of New Life Church'sTrek/Journey Awana.

Reply kathy
12:18 AM on October 6, 2013 

Just would like to know what your delivery area is. Do you deliver to West St.Paul, heard so much about your pizza would love to try it.